Every organisation makes investment
decisions that do not deliver the expected results. A new information
technology system may prove unsuitable, a construction project may become
uneconomic, or a supplier relationship may fail to achieve its objectives. When
substantial expenditure has already occurred, managers face an uncomfortable
question: should they continue investing to justify what has been spent, or
reconsider the decision in light of the evidence now available?
The difficulty arises because abandoning
a project can feel like admitting failure, particularly when public money,
shareholder investment, or management credibility is involved. However,
expenditure already incurred cannot ordinarily be recovered simply by
continuing the activity. Effective financial management requires distinguishing
between historical expenditure and future costs, ensuring previous commitments
do not unnecessarily influence decisions about resources available for
productive use elsewhere.
This distinction matters most in
procurement, supply chain management, construction, technology investment, and
public service delivery. Organisations frequently commit substantial amounts
before receiving measurable benefits, making it difficult to recognise when
circumstances have changed. The Association of Chartered Certified Accountants
(ACCA) identifies sunk costs as irrelevant to decisions where those costs
cannot be changed, regardless of which future course of action management
chooses.
Understanding sunk costs does not mean
dismissing financial losses or ignoring management accountability. Previous
expenditure remains important for financial reporting, performance evaluation,
audit, and organisational learning. The essential distinction concerns its
relevance to the next decision. Money already spent should not justify further
investment unless the expected future benefits, costs, risks, and available
alternatives provide an independently convincing business case for continuing
the activity.
What Is a Sunk Cost?
A sunk cost is expenditure already
incurred that cannot be recovered or altered by a future decision. Once an
organisation has spent money on an activity, and no alternative action can
recover that expenditure, the amount becomes irrelevant to the financial
comparison between future options. The principle applies regardless of whether
the original investment was sensible, poorly planned, commercially justified,
or ultimately unsuccessful.
Consider a manufacturer that has spent
£250,000 developing a new product. Subsequent market research indicates that
completing production will require another £100,000, while expected sales will
generate only £70,000. The original £250,000 cannot be recovered and should not
influence the immediate decision. Continuing production would generate an
additional £30,000 loss before considering other relevant effects, making
abandonment potentially the more economically sensible option.
However, distinguishing sunk expenditure
from recoverable value requires care. Machinery purchased for £500,000 may
retain a net resale value of £180,000, meaning the equipment still possesses
economic value. The original £500,000 purchase price is historical expenditure,
but the £180,000 that could reasonably be obtained through disposal represents
an opportunity cost if management retains the equipment. Any disposal charges,
contractual restrictions, or alternative uses must also be considered.
The Sunk Cost Fallacy – When Previous
Investment Distorts Judgement
The sunk cost fallacy occurs when
individuals or organisations continue an activity mainly because they have
already committed substantial resources, rather than because continuing offers
the best future outcome. Managers may believe that abandoning an unsuccessful
investment would waste what they have already spent. In reality, continuing a
commercially unjustified activity can increase losses without improving the
prospects of recovering the original expenditure.
Psychological factors contribute
significantly to this behaviour. Decision-makers may become emotionally
attached to projects they initiated, while organisational cultures sometimes
interpret cancellation as evidence of incompetence. Managers may also fear
reputational damage, criticism from senior colleagues, or scrutiny from
external stakeholders. These pressures encourage increasingly optimistic
forecasts, particularly when acknowledging deteriorating performance would
require explaining why earlier investment assumptions proved incorrect.
Imagine a logistics organisation that
has invested £750,000 in warehouse automation but discovers that the system
requires another £400,000 to achieve operational readiness. If independently
assessed future savings amount to only £250,000, continuing would create an
additional economic shortfall of £150,000, assuming no further benefits or
recoverable values. The £750,000 already spent matters for accountability, but
not as justification for committing another £400,000.
For such comparisons to be meaningful,
projected benefits and additional expenditure must be assessed over the same
relevant investment period. Where cash flows arise at different times, their
present values should be considered. Organisations must also account for
ongoing maintenance, system upgrades, implementation risks, and any recoverable
asset values. Otherwise, apparently straightforward financial comparisons may
conceal significant differences in the true economic consequences of continuing
or abandoning an investment.
This distinction matters most when
projects face repeated delays. Each additional investment can create greater
pressure to continue, even as the commercial justification deteriorates.
Organisations can reduce this risk through independent project reviews, revised
forecasts, clear termination criteria, and governance arrangements that
separate investment approval from subsequent performance evaluation. Successful
management should reward evidence-based decisions rather than unconditional
commitment to original proposals.
Sunk Costs in Procurement and Supply
Chain Management
Procurement professionals encounter sunk
costs throughout supplier selection, contract development, tender preparation,
and contract mobilisation. Expenditure on market research, completed
evaluations, consultancy advice, and unsuccessful negotiations may become
irrecoverable. If a procurement exercise no longer meets organisational
requirements, money already spent should not automatically justify proceeding.
However, organisations must still consider contractual obligations,
cancellation charges, and the consequences of abandoning a process.
For example, a housing association might
spend £85,000 developing specifications and evaluating proposals for a planned
maintenance contract. Before award, revised asset information could demonstrate
that an alternative delivery arrangement would provide better value. The
£85,000 already incurred should not determine the selected option.
Nevertheless, the association must assess future procurement expenditure,
service disruption, legal obligations, and the commercial implications of
changing its approach.
Where a regulated procurement process
has already commenced, the contracting authority must also consider the
applicable procurement legislation, published procurement documents, and its
obligations towards participating suppliers. Identifying a more attractive
alternative does not automatically permit the authority to disregard procedural
requirements. Decisions to amend, cancel, or restart a procurement should
therefore be supported by documented commercial justification and an assessment
of the associated legal and operational consequences.
In supply chain management, sunk costs
can influence inventory decisions, distribution arrangements, and supplier
relationships. A retailer holding obsolete stock purchased for £120,000 should
not insist on recovering the original purchase price when deciding whether to
sell, recycle, or dispose of those goods. The relevant considerations include
their current realisable value, storage costs, disposal expenditure, and the
benefits of releasing warehouse capacity.
Contract management introduces
additional complexity because expenditure already incurred is not necessarily
equivalent to expenditure that remains contractually payable. A £2 million
agreement might include enforceable termination provisions, outstanding
liabilities, or compensation requirements. These amounts can affect the
financial consequences of cancellation. Procurement teams must therefore
distinguish genuine sunk costs from avoidable future expenditure, legally
binding commitments, recoverable assets, and the commercial consequences of
changing suppliers.
UK Public Sector Examples – The Cost of
Continuing or Cancelling
The British Broadcasting Corporation
(BBC) provides a significant example of unsuccessful technology investment. Its
Digital Media Initiative was cancelled in May 2013 after expenditure of £125.9
million. According to the National Audit Office (NAO), the programme’s net cost
was £98.4 million after accounting for recoveries and usable assets. The
project illustrates the importance of evaluating technical feasibility,
operational benefits, and additional expenditure before continuing substantial
investments.
The National Health Service (NHS)
National Programme for Information Technology provides another example of major
investment uncertainty. In 2008, the NAO estimated the programme’s overall cost
at £12.7 billion, expressed at 2004–05 prices. This was a projected programme
cost, not expenditure already lost. In September 2011, the government announced
that it would dismantle the programme into separate components. Although some
systems delivered benefits, implementation difficulties demonstrated the
importance of independently reassessing future expenditure and expected
outcomes.
High Speed Two (HS2) demonstrates the
scale of these considerations in national infrastructure. The NAO reported that
£46.8 billion in nominal expenditure had been incurred across the programme by
March 2026, including expenditure on the cancelled second phase. This does not
mean the entire amount was wasted or irrecoverable. Decisions about
continuation must distinguish historical spending from future construction
costs, anticipated transport benefits, cancellation liabilities, and
alternative investment opportunities.
These examples demonstrate that sunk
cost analysis is not simply about reducing expenditure. Public investments may
generate social benefits that direct revenue alone cannot capture. Transport
connectivity, healthcare quality, environmental protection, and public safety
can justify expenditure that would appear unattractive under conventional
commercial assessment. Nevertheless, previous spending should not substitute
for a properly evidenced assessment of future public benefits and costs.
Private Sector Decisions – Recognising
When an Investment Has Failed
Tesco’s experience illustrates how
substantial investment can precede a major strategic withdrawal. In April 2013,
Tesco confirmed its decision to exit the United States market after reviewing
its Fresh & Easy business. Its preliminary results reported an
approximately £1.2 billion impact on profit after tax from the United States
operations, including £169 million in trading losses and approximately £1
billion in predominantly non-cash charges, principally asset impairments and
provisions for onerous leases.
Importantly, an accounting write-down is
not necessarily the same as a sunk cost. Write-downs recognise reductions in
reported asset values, while sunk cost analysis determines which expenditure
can influence future decisions. Assets may retain disposal values, contracts
may generate future liabilities, and certain investments may produce benefits
elsewhere. Tesco’s experience illustrates strategic reassessment, not that its
entire reported loss represented economically irrecoverable expenditure.
Smaller organisations face similar
decisions, although the financial amounts may be considerably lower. A
manufacturer might invest £60,000 in specialist tooling before discovering that
a product cannot compete profitably. Continuing production simply to recover
the tooling expenditure would be inappropriate if expected future revenue
failed to cover additional operating costs. Conversely, production could remain
worthwhile if future contribution exceeded relevant costs, even when the
original investment remained unrecovered.
Financial Reporting, Governance and the
Law
Management accounting distinguishes sunk
costs from relevant costs when evaluating competing decisions. Relevant costs
are future costs or economic sacrifices that differ between available options,
while avoidable costs are expenditure that can be prevented by selecting an
alternative course of action. For example, terminating an unsuccessful contract
may avoid future service payments but create termination charges. The decision
should compare these consequences rather than concentrate on expenditure already
incurred.
Sunk costs must be distinguished from
accounting losses, depreciation, and impairment. Financial statements record
expenditure and recognise asset values according to applicable reporting
standards, regardless of whether historical costs influence future decisions.
International Accounting Standard (IAS) 36, Impairment of Assets, addresses
circumstances where an asset’s carrying value exceeds its recoverable amount.
Recognising impairment does not, by itself, establish whether continuing an
activity is commercially justified.
In the private sector, section 172 of
the Companies Act 2006 generally requires directors to act in the way they
consider, in good faith, most likely to promote the company’s success for the
benefit of its members as a whole, while considering specified wider matters.
The provision does not expressly establish sunk cost accounting rules, but
responsible investment decisions should reflect directors’ applicable statutory
duties.
Public procurement is subject to
additional statutory requirements. Section 12 of the Procurement Act 2023
establishes objectives for covered procurement, including delivering value for
money, maximising public benefit, sharing information, and acting with
integrity. Contracting authorities must also comply with applicable supplier
treatment requirements. The Act does not establish sunk cost accounting rules,
and different procurement legislation may apply in Scotland and to certain
procurements elsewhere in the United Kingdom. These distinctions must be
considered when reassessing procurement expenditure.
His Majesty’s Treasury (HM Treasury)
provides a particularly clear position through The Green Book, its guidance on
government appraisal. The 2026 edition explicitly requires practitioners to
exclude sunk costs from appraisal, because those costs cannot be changed by the
decision under consideration. However, financial reporting, affordability
assessments, contractual liabilities, and retrospective evaluation serve
different purposes and may properly require consideration of historical
expenditure.
Making Better Decisions – Looking
Forward Rather Than Backwards
Effective sunk cost management begins
with identifying the decision that remains available. Managers should establish
what will happen if the organisation continues, changes direction, postpones
investment, or abandons the activity. Each option should be evaluated using
relevant future cash flows, benefits, risks, and opportunity costs. Present
historical expenditure separately, so decision-makers can understand past
performance without letting it distort their forward-looking assessment.
A useful decision-making test is to ask
whether the organisation would commit the remaining resources if it were making
the decision today, without regard to historical expenditure. If the answer is
no, management should examine whether continuation has become commercially
unjustified. This test does not replace detailed financial appraisal, but it
helps expose emotional attachment, unrealistic recovery expectations, and
pressure to defend previous investment decisions.
A practical approach involves
periodically refreshing business cases using current market information rather
than relying on assumptions made when projects were approved. Procurement teams
should examine alternative suppliers, construction managers should revisit
completion forecasts, and finance departments should challenge unsupported
expectations of future returns. Independent scrutiny becomes particularly
important when those recommending continuation also approved the original
expenditure.
Organisations must also recognise that
cancelling an investment is not automatically the correct decision. A partly
completed project may still offer substantial value if its expected future
benefits exceed the remaining costs and risks. Equally, terminating a contract
may trigger compensation, remediation expenditure, or unavoidable service
disruption. These consequences are relevant future costs and must be evaluated
alongside the benefits of alternative arrangements.
Ultimately, sunk cost analysis aims to
improve resource allocation rather than criticise past decisions. Historical
expenditure should inform learning, financial accountability, and future
planning, but determination alone cannot recover it. Organisations that
distinguish past commitments from future value are better positioned to prevent
avoidable losses, redirect investment towards productive opportunities, and
make commercially responsible decisions when circumstances change.
Additional articles can be found at Commercial Management Made Easy. This site looks at commercial management issues to assist organisations and people in increasing the quality, efficiency, and effectiveness of their products and services to the customers' delight. ©️ Commercial Management Made Easy. All rights reserved.
Further Reading, Authoritative Sources
and UK Legislation
UK legislation
- Companies Act 2006 – Section 172:
Duty to promote the success of the company
- Procurement Act 2023 – Section 12:
Covered procurement objectives
Government guidance, accounting and case
studies
- HM Treasury – The Green Book (2026)
- ACCA – Relevant Costs
- The Open University – Relevant Cash
Flows and Sunk Costs
- Institute of Chartered Accountants
in England and Wales – IAS 36: Impairment of Assets
- NAO – BBC Digital Media Initiative
- House of Commons Public Accounts
Committee – The Dismantled National Programme for IT in the NHS
- NAO – High Speed Two Reset
- Tesco – Preliminary Results 2012/13